The Snus Museum, Stockholm (pictured).
Sweden is getting ready to eradicating cigarette smoking. Not by way of bans or moralising, however by embracing innovation. Its quiet revolution, led by tobacco-free nicotine pouches, may present Europe the way to attain its 2040 smoke-free aim quicker and with far fewer lives misplaced.
Stockholm
For many years, governments throughout Europe have invested huge sums in anti-smoking campaigns, taxation, and promoting bans. But, regardless of the slogans, the leaflets and the warnings on each cigarette packet, greater than 700,000 Europeans nonetheless die annually from smoking-related ailments. For a lot of, the dependancy to nicotine stays stronger than the urge to stop.
However there may be one nation that has quietly damaged free from the sample. Sweden – as soon as a nation of heavy people who smoke – now stands getting ready to changing into Europe’s first smoke-free society, with fewer than 5 per cent of adults nonetheless smoking. The Swedish success story has little to do with bans or coercion. As a substitute, it’s constructed on pragmatism, innovation, and a willingness to have a look at nicotine in a brand new means.
The exception
When Austria, Finland and Sweden joined the European Union on January 1, 1995, their accession treaty included a notable exception for Sweden. The EU had carried out a directive in 1989 that banned the oral use of tobacco. Nonetheless, since the usage of snus – a type of oral tobacco – was conventional and extensively practised in Sweden, the European ban was considered as a risk to this cultural observe and doubtlessly detrimental to Sweden’s EU membership.
Consequently, an exception was made for Sweden. In all different EU nations, the sale of snus is prohibited. Nonetheless, the 1994 accession settlement mandates that Sweden should guarantee these merchandise are usually not marketed in different EU member states, the place the ban stays in impact.
The Snus Museum
Snus is a crucial a part of the Swedish cultural heritage with a devoted museum in Stockholm. Nestled within the coronary heart of the Swedish capital, the Snus and Match Museum (Snus- och tändsticksmuseum) presents an intriguing glimpse into the nation’s wealthy historical past of tobacco and match manufacturing. This charming builging, positioned throughout the Skansen open-air museum on the picturesque island of Djurgården, offers a novel alternative to discover Swedish traditions and heritage. A customer learns about how Swedish snus developed over time and about matches, that are one other essential Swedish export. The Snus Museum has a comfy, historic vibe: vintage packaging, previous instruments, residence scenes, and so on.
It blends cultural historical past, social historical past and the way snus and matches affected each day life and trade with visuals corresponding to graphics, packaging and design.
Snus arrived in Sweden centuries in the past, evolving from home made moist tobacco into an industrially produced, pasteurised portion product (suppose fashionable tins and pouches). It turned culturally embedded and right this moment performs a major position in Sweden’s nicotine panorama and the worldwide harm-reduction debate.
A smoke-free society
Sweden’s smoking prevalence turned one of many lowest in Europe; many public-health analysts have argued that snus contributed by providing a non-combustible nicotine different, although this stays debated. In the meantime, novel merchandise, corresponding to white snus, have emerged and altered the market.
Swedish public well being information point out that each day use of snus is substantial and protracted, significantly amongst males, whereas smoking charges stay low in comparison with many different nations. This sample is ceaselessly a subject of dialogue in coverage debates concerning the authorized availability of snus-style merchandise as options to smoking. Latest statistics from Sweden additionally present ongoing snus use and modifications in demographics associated to its consumption.
Public-health students have taken be aware. Professor Karl-Olov Fagerström, a 79-year-old Swedish scientist identified for his essential analysis on tobacco and nicotine dependancy and considered one of Sweden’s most revered nicotine researchers, has lengthy argued that “smokeless nicotine is on the coronary heart of Sweden’s smoking decline.”
He insists that clinging to an unrealistic aim of whole nicotine eradication dangers trapping tens of millions in flamable smoking as an alternative of guiding them towards safer options. In his phrases, “Nicotine pouches are related to vastly decrease well being dangers than cigarette smoking.”
Attaining a tobacco-free society is a sensible aim. Nonetheless, making a nicotine-free society is far more difficult. Whereas we are able to work to cut back nicotine use, full eradication is unlikely, says the professor. He’s additionally the namesake of the Fagerström check, a extensively used instrument in medical workplaces worldwide for assessing the severity of nicotine dependancy.
Information signifies that nicotine consumption in Sweden is corresponding to that of different comparable nations. Nonetheless, smoking charges are considerably decrease. A examine by the World Well being Organisation (WHO) reveals that if a person in Belgium had the identical smoking habits as a person in Sweden, it may end in 11,000 fewer deaths annually in Belgium. Extrapolating this to your entire European Union, the overall variety of fewer deaths may attain 355,000 yearly, based on Professor Fagerström.
Tobacco use presents a major alternative to cut back dangerous well being penalties. Not like alcohol, which immediately damages the physique, significantly the liver, individuals use tobacco primarily to acquire nicotine. Nonetheless, the method of burning cigarettes introduces different dangerous substances that negatively have an effect on well being.
Karl-Olof Fagerström argues that nicotine, when separated from tobacco—as present in merchandise like nicotine pouches—may function a significant different to cigarettes. This shift might be significantly essential for societies aiming to eradicate smoking and reduce the medical and social hurt brought on by the widespread burning of tobacco.
Many of the hurt from cigarettes — cancers, cardiovascular and lung ailments — comes from inhaling the merchandise of burning, not from nicotine itself. When a cigarette is lit, the tobacco and components endure pyrolysis and combustion, producing smoke that’s inhaled into the lungs.
Non-combustible merchandise corresponding to snus, nicotine pouches, or e-cigarettes ship nicotine with out setting tobacco on fireplace, which dramatically reduces the degrees of those combustion-derived toxins.
What separates Sweden from the remainder of Europe
An icon within the spectacular nation’s tobacco hurt discount historical past is Swedish Match. Based greater than a century in the past, the corporate spent a lot of its existence producing matches, cigars and snus. Lengthy earlier than “hurt discount” entered the language of public well being, the corporate was creating cleaner, extra constant variations of snus beneath its Gothiatek® high quality customary, drastically decreasing nitrosamines and different dangerous compounds. This heritage proved essential when Swedish Match started re-imagining nicotine itself – not as a villain, however as a car that might be decoupled from the deadly results of burning tobacco.
The corporate’s breakthrough got here with the creation of tobacco-free nicotine pouches, now marketed beneath world manufacturers corresponding to ZYN and VOLT.
Containing pharmaceutical-grade nicotine and food-grade fillers, these small white pouches ship nicotine by way of the gum with out combustion or tobacco leaf. They’re clear, discreet, and smokeless – a contemporary Swedish different to the cigarette. Inside just some years, Swedish Match was promoting near 200 million cans of those pouches yearly, turning Sweden right into a residing experiment in what a post-smoking future would possibly seem like.
My nation was one of many first on the planet to take a unique strategy to combating tobacco smoke. And it turned out to be the precise strategy, as Sweden is on its solution to changing into the primary smoke-free nation in Europe, explains Patrik Hildingsson, VP communications of Swedish Match, throughout a complete presentation concerning the Swedish expertise.
The general public-health outcomes have been dramatic. Sweden’s lung-cancer price is now roughly half that of the European common. Charges of coronary heart illness and oral most cancers are decrease, too. Epidemiologists be aware that although nicotine use stays frequent, the harms related to tobacco smoke have collapsed. This single distinction – between nicotine and smoke – is what separates Sweden from the remainder of Europe.
It’s not the nicotine that poses a well being hazard, however smoking tobacco with the hazardous compounds produced within the cigarette burning course of, says Samuel Lundell, chairman of the Nationwide Affiliation of Snus Customers (Snusarnas Riksförbund). I don’t perceive why snus is banned outdoors of Sweden, as it’s much less dangerous than burning tobacco in a cigarette. Cigarettes are allowed, however snus just isn’t. That isn’t very logical.
European Fee tax
But at the same time as Stockholm celebrates its success, policymakers in Brussels are contemplating measures that might undermine it. The European Fee has revealed the revision of the Tobacco Taxation Directive (TED) in July this yr. The revision goals to lift minimal excise responsibility charges—taxes levied on particular items, corresponding to tobacco, sometimes on the level of manufacturing or import.
Beneath the brand new guidelines, the scope of the directive would even be broadened to incorporate e-cigarette liquids, chewing and nasal tobacco, nicotine pouches, different nicotine merchandise, and uncooked tobacco.
On the similar time, the EU government proposed an extra tax referred to as Tobacco Excise Responsibility Personal Useful resource (TEDOR), which it estimates may elevate round €11.2 billion a yr for the EU’s long-term finances for 2028–2034, by taking 15% of nationwide tobacco tax revenues.
Nonetheless, this proposal is anticipated to face resistance within the Council: 14 EU member states – together with Sweden, Romania, Italy, Greece, Austria and Portugal – have already expressed opposition to TEDOR. Swedish Finance Minister Elisabeth Svantesson has strongly opposed the EU proposal, calling it “fully unacceptable”.
The logic of each EC tax proposals seems paradoxical: a coverage designed to guard well being by discouraging smoking might find yourself penalising the instruments which are serving to individuals cease. TEDOR would channel a part of nationwide tobacco taxes immediately into the EU finances. Critics warn that this new income mechanism dangers prioritising fiscal revenue over public-health outcomes and that it’s going to stifle innovation and push shoppers in direction of illicit markets. Europol, in its personal reporting, has drawn a transparent line between extreme excise and the expansion of tobacco smuggling throughout EU borders.
Extreme taxation or blanket regulation may make pouches as costly as cigarettes, stripping away the inducement to modify. These sorts of insurance policies may damage innovators creating different nicotine merchandise, leaving the sector to illicit suppliers with no high quality management in any respect.
Regulators are proper to insist on strict requirements to stop youth enchantment, deceptive claims, and aggressive advertising and marketing. Swedish Match has tried to deal with these points by way of clear labelling, nicotine-content disclosure, and adult-only advertising and marketing platforms. Its problem now could be to keep up credibility — each scientific and social — because the class it created strikes into the political crossfire of EU well being coverage.
Hurt discount works
The Swedish mannequin presents classes that Europe ignores at its peril. It reveals that hurt discount can work in observe, not simply concept. It demonstrates {that a} constructive partnership between regulators, scientists and accountable trade can obtain quicker public-health positive aspects than prohibition ever may. And it reminds us that ethical absolutism — the assumption that each one nicotine use is equally dangerous — has price lives by maintaining people who smoke chained to combustion.
Within the coming months, because the EU establishments and member states debate the way forward for nicotine taxation, they’d do properly to review what really occurred north of the Baltic. Sweden didn’t lecture its residents into quitting. It gave them higher selections — they usually took them. Swedish scientists offered the proof; and the Swedish individuals quietly delivered a revolution in public well being.
If Brussels genuinely needs to attain a smoke-free Europe by 2040, it should be taught from that have relatively than legislate it out of existence. Sweden has already proven the way in which. The remainder of Europe solely wants the braveness to observe.
Keep forward of the curve with NextBusiness 24. Discover extra tales, subscribe to our e-newsletter, and be a part of our rising group at nextbusiness24.com
